Evolution and Intelligent Design

Suggested by: Anne Continelli
Mar 26 Fri 7:00 PM
Location

257 Elm St
Davis Square
Somerville, MA 02144
617-629-8717

How to find us
"Look for us at the large table in the back of the cafe."

Attendance
 20  people attended.
5.00 5.008 (8 ratings)

Who organized?
Anne Continelli and Jim B

"Consider now complicated patterns which one would have thought would arise only through intelligent design" -Robert Nozick



Does a watchmaker exist for life as we know it?

As we study biology, study how well adapted we are, are we finding the the fingerprints of a intelligent designer?

To what degree can genes perceive their environment?

Are they a slave to purely random mutation?



Intelligent Design is the idea that some aspects of nature may reflect not a random set of events, but may be a result of an intelligent cause. Some of the concepts from the world of Intelligent Design include: irreducible complexity, specified complexity, and the fine-tuned universe The ID viewpoint seeks to examine the world for empirical data that demonstrates possible evidence of something more than random natural selection, but evidence of a designer.

Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection looks not to an intelligent designer, but to the idea that traits of a species that are more advantageous over many reproduction cycles win out. No designer, no involvement of a creator making choices. Just what traits enhance the species survival winning out.

Richard Dawkins is a ethologist, evolutionary biologist, who has written a number of books including his The Selfish Gene. Dawkins is a critic of the theory of creationism, making his case in books like The Blind Watchmaker.



Our guest event host Anne Continelli asks:

"I have been highly dismissive of ID, but recently, questions about whether genes can "perceive" their environment, thus affecting mutation (versus the concept of purely random mutation), have caused me to give this a second look. Of course, this is probably a much different interpretation than typical proponents of ID would subscribe to, which is why I would love to discuss it with a smart crowd. Richard Dawkins thinks we are just vehicles for genes; is there a level of "intelligence" going on to which we are not giving due respect?"


Come join us for a lively discussion of evolution, Intelligent Design, epigenetics, memes, viruses of the mind, DNA & destiny, Darwin and Dawkins.




Please Note: Inquisitive Minds looks to explore ideas, including some more controversial than others. We welcome respectful discussions and differing viewpoints. Our discussions are lightly moderated with the expectation that all speakers will be respected, and that people with differing life experiences and outlooks can enrich us all.

Photos of this Meetup

No photos yet.

Talk about this Meetup

  • You must be a member to post a comment. Join or login.

  • Anne Continelli
    Anne Continelli

    I just sent out an email about this.

    Posted Mar 26, 2010 4:20 PM
  • Evan
    Evan

    Anne, even at this late date & time, are there some websites/articles you can recommend for us all to get a primer on the current issues and latest twists in this debate ? Thanks.

    Posted Mar 26, 2010 11:05 AM

Who attended?

  • 20 attendees
    •  Very interesting topic and discussion. This was my first IM Meetup and I'll definitely be coming back. 
    • Jim B (+1 guest)
       Great job Anne! Very interesting comments from Junko, Pai, Tanya and others. Chicken in a box??? I also wondered if those tens of thousands of generations of e .coli subject to floods of glucose solution and then starvation, over and over, was some sort of metaphor for mankind and a vengeful watchmaker? 
    •  Great Discussion! I Always Love how people take a subject and examine it in unanticipated ways! 
    • Jen
       What an interesting discussion! 
    •  Great conversation, smart and thoughtful people! Will be coming to future meetups for sure... 
    •  Anne, thanks for a fascinating discussion of a difficult topic for us non-microbiologists! The smart, insightful, and, of course, beautiful attendees always create compelling, enjoyable IM meetups. 
    •  Lively discussion that covered a lot of ground while remaining respectful and courteous. Very good event! 
    • Gal
    • Ian
    • 1 former member

Our Sponsors

Diesel Cafe

Primary base for IM's discussion

Orleans

IM's Favorite Destination for Food and Drinks

Other nearby
Meetups
Why these groups?
x

The Meetup Groups shown here are topically similar to Inquisitive Minds.

Groups are more likely to be displayed here if they:

  • have a Meetup scheduled
  • have a high rating
  • have a group photo
  • are "public" and not "private"
  • have shown they are likely to stick around (older than 30 days)

Log in

  • Not registered with us yet?
or

Log in to Meetup with your Facebook account.

Sign up

or

Join this Meetup Group even quicker with your Facebook account.

By clicking the "Sign up using Facebook" or "Sign up" buttons above, you agree to Meetup's Terms of Service